Home › Style & Living › Why Expensive Wine Tastes Better: What 6,000 Blind Ratings and a Brain Scanner Reveal

Why Expensive Wine Tastes Better: What 6,000 Blind Ratings and a Brain Scanner Reveal

The same wine tastes nicer when people think it cost more. Here is what the research shows, where it wobbles, and how to use it when you shop and host.

You are standing in the wine aisle at half past five, eight people due at your flat by eight. In your left hand is a £6 Rioja with a cheerful label. In your right is a £25 bottle from the shelf above, the one with heavy glass and a dimple in the base you could rest a thumb in.

You have no real idea which tastes better. You only know that if a guest picks up the bottle, the £25 one will say something about you, and the £6 one will say something else. So you do what most of us do: you buy the dearer one and hope it was worth it.

Here is the strange part. In a narrow but real sense, it probably will be, and not because of anything in the glass.

The wine study that put price inside the brain

In 2008, Hilke Plassmann and Antonio Rangel of Caltech, working with John O’Doherty and Stanford’s Baba Shiv, published a small experiment in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences that still gets quoted at dinner tables. Twenty young adults lay in an fMRI scanner and were told they would taste five Cabernet Sauvignons, each identified only by its retail price.

There were really three wines. One, which actually sold for $5, appeared twice: once labelled $5 and once labelled $45. Another, a $90 bottle, appeared once at $90 and once at $10. A third wine at $35 was a distractor.

The volunteers rated the same liquid as more pleasant when they believed it was pricier, for both of the repeated wines. Ratings of how intense the taste was did not move. In the scanner, the “expensive” sips produced more activity in the medial orbitofrontal cortex, an area at the front of the brain linked with how pleasant an experience feels. Areas that handle the raw sensory signal of taste showed no price effect at all.

That distinction matters. The price did not seem to change what the tongue reported. It changed how much the brain enjoyed the report.

Two honest caveats sit inside the paper itself. The authors noted that volunteers may have been reluctant to tell an experimenter that a cheap wine tasted better. And when the same people tasted the wines again eight weeks later with no prices shown, they reported no differences between them. Twenty people, all aged 21 to 30, is also a very small sample.

A later study by Liane Schmidt, Plassmann and colleagues, published in Scientific Reports in 2017, repeated the idea with 30 volunteers. Everyone drank wines that really cost €12, shown at €3, €6 or €18. Higher price tags again raised pleasantness ratings, with the brain’s valuation network, including the ventromedial prefrontal cortex and ventral striatum, doing the work. One detail is easy to miss: compared with a blind baseline, the price cue mostly dragged down the €3 wines rather than lifting the €18 ones. Making people pay a small share of the stated price made no measurable difference.

Two glasses of red wine side by side on a wooden table
In lab studies, the same wine poured into two glasses could earn different ratings depending on the price people were shown. Photo: Vidar Nordli-Mathisen on Unsplash.

The energy drink that worked better at full price

Price does not only nudge pleasure. It can seem to change performance.

In a 2005 paper in the Journal of Marketing Research, Baba Shiv, Ziv Carmon and Dan Ariely gave people an energy drink marketed as sharpening the mind, then asked them to solve word puzzles. In psychologist Art Markman’s account of the work, the drink was SoBe, and some people were told it cost the regular $1.89 while others were told it had been marked down to $0.89.

Across three experiments, people who got the discounted drink solved fewer puzzles than those who paid full price for the identical product. The researchers argued that expectations drove the gap, and that this seemed to happen without people being aware of it.

The price tag does not change what is in the bottle. It changes what you are listening for.

Placebo pills and the price of feeling better

Shiv, Carmon and Ariely, with Rebecca Waber, then took the idea somewhere more uncomfortable. In a short 2008 letter in JAMA, they described giving 82 volunteers a light electric shock to the wrist before and after taking a pill described as a new painkiller. It was a placebo.

Half read a brochure pricing it at $2.50 a dose. The other half were told it had been marked down to 10 cents. According to Duke University, 85% of the full-price group reported less pain afterwards, against 61% of the discount group. Ariely called it a relatively small, simplified experiment, and it was. But it fits the wine and energy drink findings closely enough to be hard to dismiss.

This is not a reason to buy the expensive version of anything in a pharmacy. It is a reminder that expectations are part of how experiences are built.

What happens when nobody knows the price

If price shapes pleasure, the obvious test is to hide it. That is what Robin Goldstein, Johan Almenberg, Anna Dreber and colleagues did, publishing in the Journal of Wine Economics in 2008.

They gathered 6,175 ratings from 17 blind tastings across the United States between April 2007 and February 2008. Some 506 people tasted 523 wines priced from $1.65 to $150 a bottle. Neither the servers nor the tasters knew anything about each wine except its colour.

For the roughly 88% of tasters with no wine training, the relationship between price and enjoyment ran slightly the wrong way. Translated to a 100-point scale, a wine costing ten times more was predicted to score about four points lower. The 12% or so with some training, such as a sommelier course, leaned the other way, but that result was only weakly significant, and the authors left open whether it was real.

The sample had limits. Volunteers were unpaid and skewed towards educated people and those working in food and wine. Still, the core finding was hard to shrug off: take away the label and most people do not enjoy dearer wine more.

Does telling people the price help or hurt?

In 2011, Almenberg and Dreber followed up with an experiment in Boston and Cambridge, Massachusetts, involving 266 people. One group tasted a $40 wine and another a $5 wine. Within each, some were told the price before tasting, some after tasting but before rating, and some not at all.

Telling women the $40 price before they tasted raised their ratings by about 11 points on a 100-point scale. No other change reached conventional statistical significance, including any drop for the $5 wine. The authors concluded that hosts lose little by revealing a low price and may gain by revealing a high one. It is a single study, so the gender gap is best treated as a lead to follow up rather than a rule.

StudyWhat people were toldWhat happened
Plassmann et al. (2008), 20 peopleSame wine shown at $5 and $45Higher pleasantness and more medial orbitofrontal activity at $45
Shiv, Carmon & Ariely (2005)Energy drink at full or discounted priceDiscount group solved fewer puzzles
Waber et al. (2008), 82 peoplePlacebo painkiller at $2.50 or 10 cents85% vs 61% reported less pain
Goldstein et al. (2008), 6,175 ratingsNothing: fully blindNon-experts slightly preferred cheaper wines
Almenberg & Dreber (2011), 266 people$40 or $5 price, before, after or neverOnly women told $40 beforehand rated it clearly higher
Five studies on price and experience, with sample sizes where reported.

Is the price placebo as strong as it sounds?

Probably not as strong, or as universal, as the 2008 headlines suggested.

In 2023, Jacqueline Kurz, Emir Efendić and Caroline Goukens of Maastricht University published six studies in Psychology & Marketing with a combined 2,842 participants, using products that earlier work had rarely tested. Higher prices reliably raised what people expected to enjoy. Once they actually tried the product, though, the effect on perceived quality and liking was not consistent. The marketing placebo, they wrote, “may be less robust or generalizable as previously assumed.”

A 2024 review by Charles Spence of the University of Oxford, in Food Research International, strikes a similar balance. Across the published wine studies, price information generally did not change ratings of taste intensity, while inflated prices did tend to lift liking for cheap to mid-priced wines. He cites a 2021 study by Werner and colleagues in which pricing the cheapest wine at CHF 40 instead of CHF 10 raised pleasantness ratings by about half a point on a six-point scale. Real, then, but modest.

The fair summary is that price shapes expectation reliably, and expectation shapes pleasure some of the time, especially when the wine is ordinary and the label is visible.

Friends sharing red wine around a dinner table
Pouring from a carafe or in the kitchen takes the label out of the conversation, which removes the price cue in both directions. Photo: Fantesca Estate & Winery on Unsplash.

What this means when you shop and host

None of this makes you a fool for buying the £25 bottle. Some of what you are buying is the story, and stories are worth something. You can just be cannier about when you pay for them.

If nobody will see the label, buy cheaper. In Goldstein’s blind tastings, spending more bought untrained drinkers nothing they could taste, and the trend even tilted slightly towards the cheaper bottles. Only the trained minority showed any sign of rewarding price, and their predicted ratings did not overtake everyone else’s until about $25.70 a bottle.

Watch the cheap label more than the dear one. The 2017 brain-scanning study suggests a low price can actively spoil a decent wine. If your £6 bottle is good, you do not need to advertise the £6.

Decant, or simply pour in the kitchen. A carafe removes the price cue in both directions. Guests remember the evening more than the bottle anyway, as the peak-end rule suggests.

Remember the rest of the table matters too. Expectation does not only come from price tags. Research on plate colour and taste shows the setting shapes flavour as well, so candles, decent glasses and a warm room will do some of the work your wallet would otherwise do.

Do not agonise in the aisle. The evidence on choice overload suggests a smaller shortlist makes people happier with whatever they pick. Choose a price ceiling, grab something that looks pleasant, and get home.

So: the £6 bottle, poured from a jug, with the lights low. Your guests will enjoy it. And if one of them asks what it is, you can smile and say you will tell them after the second glass.

Official links and research

  • Almenberg, J., & Dreber, A. (2011). When does the price affect the taste? Results from a wine experiment. Journal of Wine Economics, 6(1), 111–121. DOI
  • Goldstein, R., Almenberg, J., Dreber, A., Emerson, J. W., Herschkowitsch, A., & Katz, J. (2008). Do more expensive wines taste better? Evidence from a large sample of blind tastings. Journal of Wine Economics, 3(1), 1–9. Link
  • Kurz, J., Efendić, E., & Goukens, C. (2023). Pricey therefore good? Price affects expectations, but not quality perceptions and liking. Psychology & Marketing, 40(6), 1115–1129. DOI
  • Markman, A. (2011, March 1). Your beliefs affect the strength of the placebo effect. Psychology Today. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/ulterior-motives/201103/your-beliefs-affect-the-strength-the-placebo-effect
  • Plassmann, H., O’Doherty, J., Shiv, B., & Rangel, A. (2008). Marketing actions can modulate neural representations of experienced pleasantness. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 105(3), 1050–1054. DOI
  • Schmidt, L., Skvortsova, V., Kullen, C., Weber, B., & Plassmann, H. (2017). How context alters value: The brain’s valuation and affective regulation system link price cues to experienced taste pleasantness. Scientific Reports, 7, 8098. DOI
  • Shiv, B., Carmon, Z., & Ariely, D. (2005). Placebo effects of marketing actions: Consumers may get what they pay for. Journal of Marketing Research, 42(4), 383–393. DOI
  • Spence, C. (2024). Cognitive influence on the evaluation of wine: The impact and assessment of price. Food Research International, 187, 114411. DOI
  • Waber, R. L., Shiv, B., Carmon, Z., & Ariely, D. (2008). Commercial features of placebo and therapeutic efficacy. JAMA, 299(9), 1016–1017. DOI

Cover photo: Javier Balseiro on Unsplash. Other photography by Vidar Nordli-Mathisen and Fantesca Estate & Winery on Unsplash.

How we reported this. Every figure was checked against the 9 sources above. Reviewed by Valentino Adkins, Senior Content Manager. Report an error · How we work

Follow Something Navy

Never miss a Something Navy story

Add us as a preferred source on Google and our new stories will appear more often in your Top Stories and search results.

Add us on Google
About the authorSomething Navy.
Brooke Hilland avatar

Written and edited by

Senior Content Manager· Something NavySenior Content Editor· Something NavySenior Content Strategist· Something NavySenior Editor· Something NavyWeb Content Manager· Something NavySenior Content Editor· Something Navy