Sign up for #SNApproved reads, exclusive announcements, and automatic inclusion in exciting giveaways!

Something Navy Fashion Something Else
All Home Beauty Lifestyle Kids
Shop Sphere Subscribe
Shop Sphere
Shop Sphere

SN Approved: Cookie

I went on a hunt for the best cookie in NYC.  This is what I found:

Size guide: using hand
Sweet-to-Savory Scale: (1 = savory , 5 = sweet)

1. Chip (#1)-Chocolate Chip Cookie:

Size of palm
3.8 on Sweet-to-Savory Scale

There’s nothing Chip can do to make this cookie better. They’re packaged neatly, served warm, and paired perfectly with a scoop of ice cream. The best part is splitting the perfectly toasted outer layer in half to reveal the gooey inside. Oh, and if you’re looking for chocolate chips-this cookie doesn’t disappoint.

2. Insomnia-Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cookie:

Size of palm
3 on Sweet-to-Savory Scale

My favorite candy is Reese’s Peanut Butter cups, and so obviously I love this cookie. It’s the perfect balance between salty and sweet, and a great alternative to Chip if you’re not looking for something as raw.

3. Milk Bar-Cornflake Marshmallow Cookie:

Size of palm
2 on Sweet-to-Savory Scale

Sadly, this was not my favorite. It was served packaged, and didn’t taste as fresh as the others. If you’re looking for something fully cooked and that falls on the saltier side, this is your cookie.

Illustration by: Molly Keene

By Nikki Weisman

0 Comments Join the Conversation

You Might Also Like